Interesting... I have no idea who would be considered the "biggest star", but I'm wondering if this happens in a future or present event? And finally we find out what Sylar does with those brains.

I was thinking about this earlier. Biggest could be a number of different people, and some Heroes would be able to fight back, if Sylar attacked them (Peter & Matt)

Biggest star has got to be either Hiro, Claire or Peter.

That statement about who we consider to be the biggest star is very vague to say the least lol bear in mind I've only seen half of the second series, but from what I hear, Adam Monroe ends up buried alive? Well, considering Adam Monroe is the immortal and obviously the oldest character, and actually a legendary figure as Kensei Takeso, wouldn't it be fair to say he is the biggest star, one of the originals and literally part of history? And his symbol has appeared in pretty much every episode, isn't that very symbolic if it originated from him? If anything that makes him the biggest in my opinion... plus his ability would be a nice little replacement for what the cheerleader could have offered Sylar, if you catch my drift.

For someone, maybe. For me, they are "artificially created" and I think that the real stars, or at least the most important are Bennet, Mohinder and Nathan.
But everybody thinks different - in S2, I was annoyed by Peter and Claire. And I am not alone. And someone wasnīt, what do I know?

I think itīs time for them to explain why does Sylar open brains. I think he needs to look inside to see how it "works". Just like with the watches.

But bear in mind that was written by Kristin from E!, so her interpretation of the star is going to be different. Mohinder and Nathan might be important in the show but I think if you asked the average casual viewer, or even non-viewer they would say that Claire or Hiro were the stars of the show.

Obviously it has to be Peter or Hiro, and it indicates for sure that we are going to start off in the future.

Toss of a coin really on who it will be out of these two, but for the shock factor you would lean more towards Hiro. The wait is getting to me, its that bad I was thinking of going on incapacity benefit with Heroes withdrawal, not to sure if the government will have that though

I was thinking "biggest star" could be Elle? They did say that they where trying to get her back for a least 5 episodes... Maybe they could only get her back for 2.

Also, if Peter is the "biggest star" that Sylar kills, and Peter is the one who shoots Nathan - Maybe it's really Sylar from the future!?

Is a possibilty

I'm beggining to think it's Elle....she was great in S2 and the sheer fact that they didn't kill her in S2 finale showed that she was staying and is the pathway of a "big star"...but all the news about her not being in S3 and being in talks and negotiotations till now makes me think maybe her head will pop off...

On the good side, we get to see whether "Sy-baby"(where the hell did she come with this name?) does after he slices foreheads.....mmmmm...

Biggest stars are the main characters of the show.

Off topic I know but I was watching Along Came Polly the other day and Masi Oka is in it

So?

Elle aint one the main characters, so I doubt it will be her.

Yeah, but she was on her way to be one...everyone thought she was gonna be one...and the article says "Sylar slices open the head of the person you may consider the show's biggest star! " ... sooo...I think she's the one!...

If you like

er...Thankyou?

Count me out of your everyone.

I'm inclined to believe it's one of the Three: Peter, Hiro or Claire. I wish it was Hiro, though, because Claire has been sylar'd once in the Five Years Gone verse, and Peter - well, frankly the mere idea scares the heck out of me, even if it's only alternate timeline. I'm going with Hiro. That way we could have both Sylar and Peter dublicate from the future messing with the past.

I don't think it's Hiro as he has that new arch nemesis Daphne.

I was thinking would it be funny and lame if it was Nathan. He survives two gun shots to the chest -
to then get killed by Sylar. Kinda like a D.L. scenario from Season 2.

But seriously, I'm thinking if it's a future event it'll be out of: Peter, Angela, Claire or Elle.
If it's present day: Elle. (If you watch the preview they showed in Dec, there's the whole Sylar - Elle confrontation).

Okay!

But yeah, Hiro syalar'd in the future would be nice! he could go back to the past and eat everyone up! End of Heroes...lol...thats a dangerous power....the writer's better know how to make a good one out of this...if this is what they're doing that is

When I heard 'Biggest stars', I first thought of Cristine Rose or Stephen Tobolowsky, as they are big stars outside of Heroes anyway, and who's to decide whether they meant the Characters or the Actors?