Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Claire's Father?
Got Heroes > Heroes: Episode Discussion > Volume Two: Generations > Chapter 07 - "Out of Time"
chadrowan22
I know that we found out that Nathan Petrelli is Claire's "real" father, but wouldn't it be interesting if we found out it was truly Adam Monroe??? They both have blonde hair and the same power... and who's to say Claire's mom didn't get around?

Does anyone know if they did a DNA test or something that I missed??
beddall
don't think there was ever a DNA test or anythign but from what i can gather....Adam would have been imprisoned at the time of claire's conception.
chimps_n_pimps
adam wont be claires father....as for grandfather? maybe. he could have been arthur befor he was adam
Admiralkirk
Certainly possible. Begs the question, are some powers hereditary or dominant in nature.

On a related note, I'm wondering who is Elle's father -- is it Bob or is it maybe Adam?
shanniee
QUOTE(Admiralkirk @ Nov 6 2007, 10:04 PM) *
Certainly possible. Begs the question, are some powers hereditary or dominant in nature.

On a related note, I'm wondering who is Elle's father -- is it Bob or is it maybe Adam?

Seems to me that its Bob if you looked at the preview wink.gif
chimps_n_pimps
yep...untill the preview i thought she (elle) was adams daughter, but then the whole he's nt a toy thing came up and i though oh.....bob baby girl it is.....
shanniee
QUOTE(chimps_n_pimps @ Nov 6 2007, 10:14 PM) *
yep...untill the preview i thought she (elle) was adams daughter, but then the whole he's nt a toy thing came up and i though oh.....bob baby girl it is.....

I had the exact same thought at the scne ! biggrin.gif
I was like: Baby girl oh my biggrin.gif
chimps_n_pimps
dont you think that elle's morals are a relection on what bob truely is?
shanniee
QUOTE(chimps_n_pimps @ Nov 6 2007, 10:18 PM) *
dont you think that elle's morals are a relection on what bob truely is?

Hmm your right biggrin.gif
Elle is morally grey the opposite of Bob but still listens to him.
chimps_n_pimps
morally grey?

nah...elle seems to have a god complex, and no respect.......that to me show that bob is a) av ery weak parental figure, or cool.gif just as 'evil' as elle
shanniee
QUOTE(chimps_n_pimps @ Nov 6 2007, 10:30 PM) *
morally grey?

nah...elle seems to have a god complex, and no respect.......that to me show that bob is a) av ery weak parental figure, or cool.gif just as 'evil' as elle

She killed a person, the person on the other side of the phone talking to Elle said something which Elle said some regrets.
chimps_n_pimps
i just thought it sounded like a busted eenager feigning quilt to a parent.....
Greyhound
I think Elle's dad is Bob. Whoever was on the other end of the phone was pissed when they found out she killed the Irishman.
shanniee
QUOTE(Greyhound @ Nov 6 2007, 10:36 PM) *
I think Elle's dad is Bob. Whoever was on the other end of the phone was pissed when they found out she killed the Irishman.

True, which indicates a little, that the person who talked with Elle has some moral wink.gif
Jake Hawk
QUOTE(chadrowan22 @ Nov 6 2007, 09:03 PM) *
I know that we found out that Nathan Petrelli is Claire's "real" father, but wouldn't it be interesting if we found out it was truly Adam Monroe??? They both have blonde hair and the same power... and who's to say Claire's mom didn't get around?

Does anyone know if they did a DNA test or something that I missed??


I don't think they'd add up yet another "Hey I'm your real father" twist to Claire's plot. Finding out she was Nathan's daughter was enough, imo. Having Adam be her true real father would be stretching it a bit ^^
However... I think there is definitely something going on, about those hereditary powers... First, it looked like there was no relation whatsoever between a character's powers and his parents' powers (Meredith burns plus Nathan flies equals Claire heals ; DL phases plus Nikki kicks a** equals Micah talks to machines, and so on). It seemed totally random, which made any connection between Nathan and West or between Adam and Claire irrelevant. But now we've seen that Matt has the exact same power as his father does... So, random or not ?
shanniee
QUOTE(Jake Hawk @ Nov 6 2007, 11:04 PM) *
I don't think they'd add up yet another "Hey I'm your real father" twist to Claire's plot. Finding out she was Nathan's daughter was enough, imo. Having Adam be her true real father would be stretching it a bit ^^
However... I think there is definitely something going on, about those hereditary powers... First, it looked like there was no relation whatsoever between a character's powers and his parents' powers (Meredith burns plus Nathan flies equals Claire heals ; DL phases plus Nikki kicks a** equals Micah talks to machines, and so on). It seemed totally random, which made any connection between Nathan and West or between Adam and Claire irrelevant. But now we've seen that Matt has the exact same power as his father does... So, random or not ?

I say random.....
There is a chance that a parent and his child will have the same ability but it is very slim.
Matt just so happens to have that ability.
starwarsgeek
QUOTE(Jake Hawk @ Nov 6 2007, 02:04 PM) *
I don't think they'd add up yet another "Hey I'm your real father" twist to Claire's plot. Finding out she was Nathan's daughter was enough, imo. Having Adam be her true real father would be stretching it a bit ^^
However... I think there is definitely something going on, about those hereditary powers... First, it looked like there was no relation whatsoever between a character's powers and his parents' powers (Meredith burns plus Nathan flies equals Claire heals ; DL phases plus Nikki kicks a** equals Micah talks to machines, and so on). It seemed totally random, which made any connection between Nathan and West or between Adam and Claire irrelevant. But now we've seen that Matt has the exact same power as his father does... So, random or not ?


Well, Linderman did set up Niki and DL because of their potential. Appearently, there is a way to track it.
shanniee
QUOTE(starwarsgeek @ Nov 7 2007, 12:16 AM) *
Well, Linderman did set up Niki and DL because of their potential. Appearently, there is a way to track it.

Maybe if both parents have abilities... but it isnt entirely stated for sure yet. About the 2 parents having powers so will the child is hard to say whether what is true and what is false. So many questions unanswered and hopefully a few key questions will be answered in the next episode.
MrJP
Maybe Adam is Elle's real father and Bob just adopted her... or maybe even better, Adam gets laid alot and he is the father (or grandfather or even great grandfather) of all those with powers! and Chandra was angry and Adam and made a formula to make expectation of where Adam would go, to find out where Adam would go, check all it's population for women which Adam might like and calculate the possible offspring they could have. That would make DL and Nikki!!!!! eeewhh.....
starwarsgeek
QUOTE(MrJP @ Nov 6 2007, 03:39 PM) *
Maybe Adam is Elle's real father and Bob just adopted her... or maybe even better, Adam gets laid alot and he is the father (or grandfather or even great grandfather) of all those with powers! and Chandra was angry and Adam and made a formula to make expectation of where Adam would go, to find out where Adam would go, check all it's population for women which Adam might like and calculate the possible offspring they could have. That would make DL and Nikki!!!!! eeewhh.....


... dry.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.