QUOTE(starwarsgeek @ Nov 9 2007, 09:15 PM)

Have you seen 1x20 ("Five Years Gone")? Near the end, the Hatian was going to block Peter's and Hiro's powers so they could be shot. Had this power only worked on mental abilities, Peter could have used many, amny powers to stop everyone's favorite unnamed character, namely: sneak up on him with invisability, use super speed to run along and disarm everyone (he copied it in a graphic novel), use fire (hard to tell if that was ted or clair's mom [forgot name], but either way, it's not mental.
As you can see, the Hatian would have been no threat to Peter. But what were they doing? Sneaking through to grab Hiro (or possibly kill the Hatian while he had no back-up.) Why would Peter bother with the sneaking if bending space/time continuum, TK, and telepathy were the only powers he couldn't use.
Now earlier in the season, we saw the Hatian being useless against Peter and Nathan. Keep in mind that he was following Mama P's orders. She wouldn't want her children bagged+tagged, now would she?
You make some good points. And, while I still believe that his ability only deals with the mind, this is part of the reason I hope we get a fuller explanation. I have a theory, you have a theory, others have theories, and we don't have enough facts to rule out enough theories.
QUOTE(starwarsgeek @ Nov 9 2007, 09:15 PM)

As you can see, the Hatian would have been no threat to Peter. But what were they doing? Sneaking through to grab Hiro (or possibly kill the Hatian while he had no back-up.) Why would Peter bother with the sneaking if bending space/time continuum, TK, and telepathy were the only powers he couldn't use.
My best guess (in defense of my theory, of course

) is that, yes, he could still use his other awesome powers to benefit himself, but he would also have FHiro and Ando, both relatively powerless, to defend and bring along with him (and, on the way out, both FHiro and PHiro). Better to sneak-n-hide in and sneak-n-hide out while they're together than to try to go in both with guns ablazin' AND trying to defend three people simultaneously.
QUOTE(starwarsgeek @ Nov 9 2007, 09:15 PM)

She wouldn't want her children bagged+tagged, now would she?
This begs one or both of two questions:
Why were HRG and the Haitian after Nathan in early S1?
If the Haitian were able to block any power, how did Nathan fly away?
Of course, an answer to one could render the other obsolete. I'll have to go back and see why they were after Nathan.
Edit: transcript from when they grab Nathan (epi 1/05):
Nathan: "Do you have any idea who I am??"
HRG: "Better than even you."
Nathan: "Fine, look, I'll pay you, okay? You name it."
HRG: "We don't want anything, We just need to know a couple of things, that's all."
*HRG answers cell, Nathan attacks, Nathan runs, gets caught at the chain link fence*
HRG: "That was entirely unnecessary."
Nathan: "Might as well go ahead and shoot now. I'll find you, I will kill you."
HRG: "Unlikely, Mr. Petrelli."
Nathan: "I've seen your faces."
HRG: "That, I'm afraid, won't be a problem. [to the Haitian] Put him down."
At which point Nathan and the Haitian get into their boxing stances, and Nathan shoots off.
So, unfortunately, no detail about
why they're after him.