Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The Watchmen
Got Heroes > Heroes: In Other Formats > Other Superheros On The Screen
bubbles
so, do we have any love for watchmen here ??

surely on a heroes fan site we can agree the crux of season 1 was pretty similar to the comic ?? no ??
just me then eh ??

anyhoo, the trailers out....here, in case yr wondering.....

looking pretty dang good say i....
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
Looks pretty sweet, just a shame we have to wait so long.
bubbles
indeed, 2009 better hurry the hell up.....
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
Just finished reading the graphic novels. What else can I say, other than it was fantastic.

Its amazing how it gets away with few fight scenes, even the finale isnt really a fight scene.

Also it draws you into the Universe as a lot of the events in the novel are events that happened in real life.

I just worry a bit though as the comic is driven mostly by complex character dynamics that translating on to film may prove difficult, especially with a cast with so little experience. But we'll see.
bubbles
20th century fox is dead to me....DEAD.

Useless money grubbing people....i hope something really nasty befalls all of them...or better yet i hope they get their fingers broken by Rorschach....

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/7569770.stm

NOOOOOOO
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
25 minutes of Watchmen was aired to fans recently,... though no clips as yet as of yet. But heres an article about it from WatchmenComicMovie.com.

I know. You’ve all been waiting to hear my report on the Watchmen footage I saw last night. Well, here’s how the night went down.

As soon as all of the invited guests were seated in the Warner Brother’s screening room at their palatial offices in New York City, DC Comics president Paul Levitz took the stage to get the party started.

Levitz explained that with the exception of Watchmen illustrator Dave Gibbons, who was also present that evening, nobody had been waiting longer than him for the comic series to be made into a movie.

After praising director Zack Snyder for helping him sell an extra million copies of the trade paperback since the movie trailer was released, he introduced the director who cautiously took the stage.

Snyder told the audience that he got interested in comics by way of a subscription to the über sexy and violent Heavy Metal magazine. After that, he explained that whenever he picked up a regular comic book he would think, “nobody's really fuckin’ or dyin’ in this, so I don’t get it.” So when he saw Watchmen, it immediately appealed to him.

Snyder explained that he knew adapting Watchmen into a film would be very difficult, so he approached the process by using key panels of the comic as his storyboard and then just filled in the shots in between those panels with sketches of his own.

The first clip that was shown was the first ten or so minutes of the movie which included retired hero Eddie Blake being attacked and killed by an unknown assailant in his apartment which lead into the opening credits of the film.

Now, in the comic, the Blake murder is shown as a flashback as police are investigating the crime scene, but in the film, it’s been fully fleshed out as a scene all of its own — and what a scene it is.

It starts with the camera pulling back slowly from a close-up on the smiley face badge pinned to the robe of the retired Edward Blake a.k.a. The Comedian. He’s making a cup of tea while watching the McLaughlin Group on late night T.V. The topic of the show is Russia — are they stockpiling nuclear weapons in preparation for an attack on the U.S, or are they still too afraid to provoke the United States because Dr. Manhattan is on our side? McLaughlin mentions that the atomic board of scientists has even recently moved the Doomsday Clock to five minutes to midnight due to the Soviets activities and asks the pundits on his show to comment on the situation.

As the pundits discuss, Blake takes his tea into his living room and plops into his easy chair. He starts flipping channels and stops on a commercial. Nat King Cole’s song “Unforgettable” plays over a scene with a beautiful couple relaxing and swimming in a pool by a luxurious mansion. It’s a commercial for Nostalgia Perfume. Blake smiles, some of the tension leaving his body. You can tell that he must really like the song.

BAM! Cut to the door of his apartment being kicked open by a dark figure wearing all black with a wool hat. Blake stands quickly than says, “Just a matter of time, I suppose.”

Blake looks down and sees that his gun is on the coffee table, resting atop a copy of “Hustler” magazine. He slowly pours the tea out of his cup, then quickly hurls it at the intruder. The intruder ducks, and the cup smashes onto the open door busting the apartment number which was 3002, to now read 300 (easter egg!)

Blake grabs his gun and points it at his assailant, by he's too quick. He attacks Blake and disarms him, but not before a shot is fired which goes into the T.V. screen which is still playing the commercial. Now the Nat King Cole song continues playing as the soundtrack for the fight.

The fight is fierce and violent with each combatant trading wild attacks that are fairly exaggerated. Walls are punched through, knives are thrown and caught, heads and bodies are smashed through tables and countertops.

As Blake stands at the end of the melee, face covered in blood, he smiles at his attacker and says, “It’s a joke. It’s all a joke.” A blood drop falls from his face and onto his smiley badge. Then, the assailant lifts Blake up with one arm and throws him through the plate glass window.

The camera follows Blake and the button down to the sidewalk where he lands. As blood flows from the dead hero’s body, the smiley badge lands next to him, bounces a few times, then slowly settles face up right by his shoulder.

Cut to the opening credits.

Accompanied by Bob Dylan's song, "The Times, They Are A'Changin'", the credit sequence takes viewers inside the whole history of masked heroes with many shots representing an alternate take on real-life historical events. Some of the scenes shown included:

— The Minutemen assembling for a group shot in their meeting room.

— Nite Owl I brawling with some thugs.

— A young, mustache-less Eddie Blake (a.k.a. The Comedian) posing for the press with two crooks he’s apprehended.

— Mothman screaming wildly as he's being dragged into a paddy wagon.

— Sally Jupiter (a.k.a Silk Spectre I) posing with police for a press photo.

— Masked hero Dollar Bill lying dead on the floor with his cape stuck in a bank’s revolving door.

— The Enola Gay dropping the A-Bomb on Hiroshima with an image of Silk Spectre I painted on it's nose.

— Ursula Zandt (a.k.a The Silhouette), the Minutemen's lesbian member, grabbing a young woman celebrating Japan’s surrender in New York, for an alt-universe version of that famous Life magazine shot.

— The Silhouette found murdered in bed with her lover with the words, "Lesbian Whores" written in their blood on the wall.

— A pregnant Silk Spectre I retiring from the Minutemen set up to look like Da Vinci’s “Last Supper” painting.

— Kruchev and Castro in a snowy Red Square watching jets do a fly-by over their heads.

— A young Walter Kovacs being patted on the head by a “john” as another heads into his mothers room for his “turn.”

— Doctor Manhattan shaking J.F.K.’s hand on the White House lawn.

— Kennedy being killed by The Comedian who shoots from the “grassy knoll.”

— An Apollo astronaut walking on the moon while Dr. Manhattan standing naked on the moon’s surface video tapes the event.

— Andy Warhol and Truman Capote speaking in front of A Warhol Pop Art painting of Nite Owl.

— A young Laurie standing in a dark hallway as her parents argue loudly.

— Flower children getting shot by American G.I.’s

— Adrian Veidt (a.k.a. Ozymandias) hanging out in front of New York City’s famous Studio 54 with the Village People and David Bowie.

— The Watchmen (Crimebusters) posing for a group shot.

—The Keane Riots on the streets of New York and a molotov cocktail being thrown through a store window.

— Term limits being eliminated on the U.S. presidency, insuring Nixon’s remaining in office through 1985.

The next scene that was previewed takes place after Dr. Manhattan flees to Mars. It covers all of the flashbacks that encompass the past history of Jon Osterman, and the accident that leads to him becoming Dr. Manhattan.

Not every flashback that appears in the comic is in this sequence. Many of the flashbacks that were seen were almost identical in dialog and panel composition as in the comic. Some of the changes included Wally Weaver now being Osterman’s old college buddy and the watch that was left in the intrinsic chamber is Osterman’s not Janey’s.

Now some of the material that was left out of this scene is not cut from the film and will appear someplace else in the movie — like the Crimebusters meeting or the Vietman War sequences. Even the scene where he shakes hands with J.F.K appears in the opening credits instead.

The last scene shown begins right after Dan and Laurie have consummated their love on the Owl Ship after rescuing victims of a tenement fire. Dan and Laurie are naked in each other's arms with their costume components strewn all over the floor.

Dan tells Laurie that they have an obligation to their crime fighting brethren and need to break Rorschach out of prison. Laurie tells Dan that it will be a lot more difficult doing that than saving fire victims. Dan smiles coyly and tells her, “Yes, but it will be a lot more fun too.”

In the next shot the Owl Ship swoops down over the burning prison where a riot is taking place. They both jump from the ship onto the roof and enter the prison where the rioters have gone completely wild and have overrun the entire facility.

Using some fairly coordinated and restrained martial arts moves, they battle their way down a cell block corridor dispatching any prisoners that are foolish enough to attack them.

When the finally encounter Rorschach he has retrieved his costume from (what Zack Snyder told me but was not shown in the footage they screened) the evidence box that his prison psychiatrist kept in his office.

As Dan and Laurie spot him, Rorschach is about to enter a men’s room to confront Big Figure, a diminutive con played by Danny Woodburn who he has a grudge against.

Rorschach greets them addressing Laurie as “Miss Jupiter.” He excuses himself to enter the facilities as Laurie exclaims, “Jesus Christ,” annoyed that he picked this of all times to relieve himself and not knowing he’s pursuing some “prey.” You hear the toilet flush as Rorschach exits and, as they all walk away, a pool of blood spills out from under the door.

After that, they screened some random clips, most of which were shown in the footage at Comic-Con. There were no real surprises or revelations in those clips.

The evening wrapped up with a Q&A session with Zack Snyder and Watchmen illustrator Dave Gibbons which I won’t recap here as someone from Comingsoon.net covertly recorded it.

So there you have it. Now, if you care about what my impressions were of what I saw, then read on.

Basically, I liked everything I saw. At first, though, I thought Blake’s battle with his “assailant” was a bit overdone and there attacks were very exaggerated and unrealistic. I mean, these are not real superheros with powers, just strong men with great fighting skills. I even brought this concern up with Dave Gibbons after the event and he explained to me that even though they aren’t real superheros, they are incredible people in their own right who have the best of any man’s fighting skills. So, if it's good enough for Dave…

But the reason I came around was I realized, this is one of the very iconic standoffs in the comic. The creativity in the fight scene gave it impact and importance, and as a fan, if Snyder had toned it down and made it a generic fight scene, I think I would have been let down even more. I know some fans will strongly disagree with me.

Everything else looked great and was very faithful to the comic I believe. Yes, we have some added action, and Snyder adds on a layer of his slow-motion/speed-up techniques on these sequences, but you can tell he’s showing restraint — using these techniques sparingly and only to add tension and heighten the drama where it fits.

As for Dr. Manhattan? I liked all of that as well. The one thing I would change would be to put some kind of vocal effect on Crudup's voice when he’s speaking as the Doc. The way the speech bubbles were drawn in the comic demonstrates that his voice is not like a regular person’s voice. It's not a deal breaker that it’s not there, but I still feel I'd like something there tonally — something subtle.

And performances? From the little I saw it looks like everyone has their character down. I’m going to give extra high marks to Patrick Wilson who literally channels Dan Dreiberg. Even dressed as Nite Owl you can see Dan behind the mask. I can’t explain how he does it, he just does. I got to see him do a scene when I visited the set and I felt the same way then as I do now. I can’t wait to see more of him on screen come March.
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
New footage of next years epic has just been released. The trailer starts about 1.30 min. Check out the link,....... no more heroes!!. biggrin.gif

Watchmen Scream Trailer
The Crowing
Looks great! The novel was awsome and the end REALLY shocked me! Didn't expect it at all, especially when Dr.Manhattan just kills Rorschach because he won't stay silent
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
QUOTE (TH3 JOK3R @ Oct 22 2008, 04:28 PM) *
Looks great! The novel was awsome and the end REALLY shocked me! Didn't expect it at all, especially when Dr.Manhattan just kills Rorschach because he won't stay silent


Yeah, but hes emotionless. He only sees logic. I've just read it myself recently after watching the first trailer. smile.gif

Plus matey no need for spoilers on other programs,.... its just Heroes.
The Crowing
QUOTE (GIBBY @ Oct 22 2008, 04:32 PM) *
Yeah, but hes emotionless. He only sees logic. I've just read it myself recently after watching the first trailer. smile.gif

Plus matey no need for spoilers on other programs,.... its just Heroes.


haha i know yeah, i was just taking into consideration those who won't read the novel but will watch the flim, i mean it was a pretty big bombshell for me! Also, i actually really liked ozmandious, he reminds me of superman, kinda. rolleyes.gif
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
How? laugh.gif Your picnic. tongue.gif

Edit: One thing that comes to mind, is him catching the bullet. Amazing considering he has no powers.

Trailer 2(Just the trailer + better audio)
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
Worried about the ending of Watchmen? The article is below and is quite a read. rolleyes.gif

To Squid or Not to Squid?
With all of the rumors that have been flying around the Web lately, what’s the real story about how the Watchmen movie is going to end?

Ever since news leaked from the Portland screening a few weeks ago, rumors about the ending to Zack Snyder’s film adaptation of Watchmen have been ricocheting around the Net at warp speed.

What’s it all about? Well, the following report is rife with spoilers so read on at your own risk.

The news that Zack Snyder was changing the ending to his version of Watchmen came more than a year ago when leaked drafts of David Hayter’s, and then later Alex Tse’s, screenplays hit the Web. Both scripts had an ending very different from the original comic series where Dr. Manhattan is framed for an energy beam attack on multiple cities around the world killing millions. This event frightens the US and Russia into ceasing the Cold War, and ushers in a new era of global peace — the intended outcome from the party that perpetrated this elaborate hoax.

From day one, fans (and I’m one of them) voiced their opinion that this new ending completely undermined the actual ending Alan Moore so carefully crafted back in 1985. Moore’s ending consisted of an elaborate hoax that would force the world into an era of peace as well, but did not involve Dr. Manhattan. What it did involve was a genetically engineered giant monster that's teleported into New York, instantly dies from the trip, and in it’s death throes broadcasts a psychic wave that kills millions. Fans endearingly call that monster “the squid.”

Now, I’ll be the first to admit that on the surface, Moore's ending seems a bit, well, ridiculous. But anyone who has actually read Watchmen and has absorbed all of nuances of character and subtext will tell you - it's freakin’ brilliant. I mean, Watchmen is on the list of Time Magazine's “Top 100 Best English-language novels from 1923 to the present” for crying out loud.

So, what’s wrong with the “Dr. Manhattan/Energy Beam” ending, then? Glad you asked. Here is the biggest problem most fans have with this “new” ending — framing Dr. Manhattan.

The big problem here is that from the moment Dr. Manhattan is introduced in the story, he is shown as being the pawn of the United States government. Doing the bidding of president Nixon in the name of the Stars and Stripes. He even wins the Vietnam War for the US. Would the world really believe that Dr. Manhattan is a universal threat to the world and cause them to cease hostilities against each other? Russia didn’t really trust the US back in 1985, so why would they believe Dr. Manhattan went rogue after years of faithful service to Uncle Sam? If anything, Dr, Manhattan’s attack would either escalate the Cold War or start World War III.

Now, what will make fans happy? Believe it or not it’s not a carbon copy of Moore’s original ending. Most fans understand that with any adaptation, sometimes alterations are needed. Don’t get me wrong, most fans are hoping that Snyder and company can find a way to make the “squid” ending work, but if for some reason they can’t, here are the two main aspects they feel need to be kept from Moore’s ending.

First, the “threat” needs to remain alien in nature and scary as hell. Fans tend to agree, the only way humanity could believably stop warring with each other is if they faced a new and menacing extraterrestrial enemy.

Second, the destruction this “threat” causes should include piles and piles of bloodied and battered corpses. Fans feel that audiences need to see at face value the horror of the “solution” the perpetrator of this plan has caused. In early drafts of the script, the victims of this attack get vaporized, leaving only ash — not particularly gruesome. If you look at the opening pages of Watchmen’s final chapter, you’ll understand why fans feel that kind of carnage needs to be shown. A picture is really worth a thousand words.

So where do we stand today as far as the ending is concerned. Are we getting the “squid,” a “framed Dr. Manhattan,” or something in between (whatever that may be)?

Well, if you want to catch up on all of the evidence on both sides of the fence, check out this article where we lay it all on the line, then come back here to see the balance of remaining clues. Ready? Okay.

In an MTV interview with Matthew Goode, who plays Ozymandias in the film, they asked the actor about the creature that appears at the end of the film. A quote from that article reads...

Right up there with the long-running debate over Ozymandias’ sexuality is the more recent question of how Snyder will depict the massive creature that factors into the closing chapters of the story. Although Goode said he had “no idea” how the beastie will appear on-screen, he assured fans it will look “as good as the cast you’ve already seen.”

Some fans claim that he's confirming the “squids” inclusion in the film, others surmise that Goode is being coy and saying that he'll look “as good as good as the cast you’ve already seen” because that beastie will end up being Dr. Manhattan.

Then, in a Film.com interview with Kevin Smith, who has seen the Watchmen movie no less than two times now, the director mentions the film’s ending as well.

It's a little different. While it is a slight departure, it actually makes sense in the context of the story because it brings the characters back into it. It kind of makes the movie more about them by the end of it because of the switch they made.

Again, fans interpret this both ways based on what they feel Kevin Smith might consider a “slight departure.” Although Smith’s answer verifies there has been a change made, it’s hard to tell if that change means no “squid.” In my opinion, leaving out the “squid” is more than a slight departure, but maybe Kevin doesn’t feel that way.

But the “smoking gun” is this quote taken from Zack Snyder at the Q&A session after the LA screening of the 25 minutes of footage to the press. Here’s Snyder's response to a question on how the monster at the end of his movie would look.

Well, that's, uh, uh, I'll save that one. I would say… if anything I would say that that's the, uh, that's the bit of the movie that if you read the David Hayter draft, I don't know if anyone has, that's where we, that's where I guess you could say there's some differences between the graphic novel and the movie.

I don’t know how else you can interpret that one except as a big “no squid” confirmation.

So, is all hope lost my friends? Maybe not. It seems that Rich Johnston, who writes the “Lying in the Gutters” blog on ComicBookResources.com had this to say last week.

There have been repeated reports circulating the net regarding the ending of Zack Snyder’s “Watchmen" movie that the ending has been radically changed from the original. We’re not talking everyone wearing Rorschach’s mask or anything, but the perceived and bizarre extra-world threat of a pan dimensional Cthulhu god alien landing on New York killing millions is gone.

Or has it?

I understand that the ending people have been seeing is just one possible filmed ending. That the movie’s FX farm has already created big squid effects. And that there will be more than one ending of the film tested before general release. Expect to see all of them in the two/three disc DVD.

Then, this week, he followed that bombshell up with this...

Last week's LITG talked about the different "Watchmen" endings that are being tested. And the one ending that's been seen and reported that has a bombed out New York, but no hyperdimensional alien squid.

I'm told that this screening was intentionally leaked to the fan press - with the exact time and place posted online with details of how to evade the security. The intent is to gauge fan reaction to a squidless ending for Watchmen and see what they can get away with, believing it to be more suitable for a more mainstream audience. The FX for the squid has been completed however.

Fan reaction to Johnston’s blog entries have been mixed. Some are calling him a bold faced liar who made up the story to create buzz for his blog, others are breathing a bit easier, confident that multiple endings, one of them with the “squid,” are in play.

What do I think? I think I want an ending that serves Alan Moore’s and Dave Gibbons's original vision and satisfies the die-hard fans and average movie goers alike. Yes, I think there’s an ending that can fill all of those criteria — I just hope I see that ending on March 6th.
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
New trailer for the Watchmen,...... watch and drool. biggrin.gif

http://www.watchmencomicmovie.com/111308-w...vie-trailer.php
Obi-Wan Gibnobi
I'm really suprised by how quiet this thread is, as this movie will be the blockbuster hit of 2009.

Anyways for people new to Watchmen or others that want to re-watch the novels,... heres a link for the motion comics. I really advise people to watch these as they are fantastic.

http://soundtrackloversparadise.blogspot.c...ook-highly.html
The Crowing
Yeah there ain't much love for Watchmen on here i guess. I can't wait for the film though looks pretty sweet from the promo's i have seen so far. I am concerned about how they are going to change the ending though, if they do actually change it. Roll on March 09!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.