Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Who was Claude hiding?
Got Heroes > Heroes: Episode Discussion > Volume One: Genesis > Chapter 17 - "Company Man"
TheAmazingAzn
Anyone have speculation on the person Claude was hiding from the company? My friend thinks that it was another empath like Peter since Claude seemed to have previous experience training empaths.
Jester77
Hmm quite possibly, that would be really cool too especially if the empath was still alive
FanOfHeroes
Someone from another site had a great thoery to this question. They said that maybe it was a shape shifter and that's why he was with the pigeons all the time???
CharlieJ
QUOTE(TheAmazingAzn @ Feb 26 2007, 11:12 PM) [snapback]9078[/snapback]
Anyone have speculation on the person Claude was hiding from the company? My friend thinks that it was another empath like Peter since Claude seemed to have previous experience training empaths.


It was seven years ago... Let's see, do we know of anyone (besides the Haitian) who knew of their powers seven years ago? Dale - maybe. It could have been someone we haven't met -- like Sparrow Redhouse or one of the other folks on "the list". It's definitely NOT any of the "specials" we know now. Could it have been James Walker? I would suspect it's someone who lived or lives in/near Odessa, Texas. Arthur Dowland? Teresa Hue Pham?

Jester77
QUOTE
Someone from another site had a great thoery to this question. They said that maybe it was a shape shifter and that's why he was with the pigeons all the time???


I actually really like that theory, it would definetly make sense
Supergirl
Yeah I'd love to find out who! There certainly has to be something to it.
Jester77
I'd just like to know if that person is still alive (most likely) and if so if we'll get to see them soon. This show seems to love providing more questions with the few answers we're given
Supergirl
I thought maybe it was Claire he was hiding but nah I don't think so now.
Jester77
QUOTE
I thought maybe it was Claire he was hiding but nah I don't think so now.


No that's definetly not it especially since Claire didn't even know about her power back then
lanthrax
I think it was Nathan.. Nathan has known about his powers for a while.. probably from around the time he was with Claire's mom. Or maybe his powers manifested later. Either way it could be Claude was protecting Nathan. Nathan's dad is also dead...So this "dad" could be claude..I mean he looks old enough
Jester77
QUOTE
I think it was Nathan.. Nathan has known about his powers for a while.. probably from around the time he was with Claire's mom. Or maybe his powers manifested later. Either way it could be Claude was protecting Nathan. Nathan's dad is also dead...So this "dad" could be claude..I mean he looks old enough


Maybe but I don't think so after all it would be kind of annoying if every time we were wondering who they might be referring to that it would turn out to be Nathan such as when he turned out to be Claire's biological father
Synergistic
You have to think about heroes that fit the timeline, I want to think that it was Wireless that he was hiding, although how Claude would've found out about her before she manifested, I'm not quite sure.

Lanthrax: Nathan and Peter's father was a prominent politician, an invisible man does not hide in plain sight, or in a very visible position for that matter
DCSimian
Hana's a good possibility. I don't think it was Nathan. If it was, there's a possibility that Claude would have known already about Peter and Claire, especially if he had kept tabs on Nathan all this time...all signs point the idea that it wasn't the elder Petrelli.
Tosch
While Hana's a candidate, I agree that it should be someone Claude could reach easily. That would limit him to the US, if not Texas. It's probably someone he thought would cause too many problems if the organization got them. So a shape shifter is a good possibility. I'd vote for it's someone we haven't, and most likely won't, meet. Besides, it sort of ruins the fun of speculation if we know everything.
Azkary
I think that Claude was hiding Simone. I mean think about it, Claude has lived in the roof of her father's building. She hadn't shown special abilities until last night's preview. And judging by her attitude it seemed she was quite familiar with her ability, like it was no surprise. dry.gif
lanthrax
QUOTE(Synergistic @ Feb 27 2007, 11:21 AM) [snapback]9275[/snapback]
You have to think about heroes that fit the timeline, I want to think that it was Wireless that he was hiding, although how Claude would've found out about her before she manifested, I'm not quite sure.

Lanthrax: Nathan and Peter's father was a prominent politician, an invisible man does not hide in plain sight, or in a very visible position for that matter



arite...that makes sense....hey..it was just an idea..
Uker
Idk..i immediatly thought Peter, becaue it seems as if he some sort of "connection" with him. Even at first.
Maybe he knew that Peter had the strongest ability from the start? ohmy.gif
FanOfHeroes
i don't think it's Hana that claude was hiding, because claire was a baby when all of that was going down, which means it had to be at least 16-17 yrs ago depending on claires age now. So think about the internet, e-mail, satellite communications and cell phones, 16-17 yrs ago??? How could she know about this power if technology wasn't as developed as it is today? i could be wrong though...
Jester77
QUOTE
i don't think it's Hana that claude was hiding, because claire was a baby when all of that was going down, which means it had to be at least 16-17 yrs ago depending on claires age now. So think about the internet, e-mail, satellite communications and cell phones, 16-17 yrs ago??? How could she know about this power if technology wasn't as developed as it is today? i could be wrong though...


It couldn't have been Hana she was still in Israel and she hadn't developed her power yet. A good theory but it's not her
Hero in Waiting
QUOTE(lanthrax @ Feb 26 2007, 09:45 PM) [snapback]9157[/snapback]
I think it was Nathan.. Nathan has known about his powers for a while.. probably from around the time he was with Claire's mom. Or maybe his powers manifested later. Either way it could be Claude was protecting Nathan. Nathan's dad is also dead...So this "dad" could be claude..I mean he looks old enough


LOL....how could Peter not recognize his own dad???? Na, this one wont work.
Tim Kring
Yeah... Um, I will have to wait and see!

WE WILL GET ANSWERS TO ALL OF OUR QUESTIONS! (This is not LOST!!! tongue.gif)
Hawaiianboy
QUOTE(TheAmazingAzn @ Feb 26 2007, 08:12 PM) [snapback]9078[/snapback]
Anyone have speculation on the person Claude was hiding from the company? My friend thinks that it was another empath like Peter since Claude seemed to have previous experience training empaths.



WHAT IF THE HERO THAT CLAUDE WAS HIDING WAS

[SPOILER]SIMONE[/SPOILER]
Tim Kring
QUOTE(Hawaiianboy @ Feb 27 2007, 11:23 PM) [snapback]9518[/snapback]
WHAT IF THE HERO THAT CLAUDE WAS HIDING WAS

[SPOILER]SIMONE[/SPOILER]


NO! NO! NO!

She is dead dude... and she doesn't have a power!!!
NikkiS1978
How old would Claire have been when this happened? He said something about, 'that's why you're so distant with her.' Maybe he began to suspect something about her manifesting, but was denying it to himself to ever have to turn her over to 'them.' I dunno. I guess Claude was asking that as a scenario or something. We'll find out who it was eventually. I'm kinda guessing it could be [spoiler]the new character coming up in next week's episode.[/spoiler]
Supergirl
Claire would have been like 8 or 9 I think.
Tim Kring
We will have to wait to find out. WE WILL FIND OUT! THIS IS NOT "LOST," This is HEROES, the show that actually answers some DAMNED questions!!!

-Alic wink.gif
Fox29
QUOTE(Tim Kring @ Feb 28 2007, 02:35 AM) [snapback]9524[/snapback]
NO! NO! NO!

She is dead dude... and she doesn't have a power!!!


Explain the preview then.

Actually, this all makes sense. [spoiler]Claude keeps "his" birds at the Deveux place, Simone mentioned that Charles knew about the birds, and allowed them to stay, indicating that he knew something was up. Take that, and the fact that Charles knew Claude (the scene where HRG gets Claire takes place at at Deveux Tower, where Claude is), and I think that in return for hiding Simone, Charles hid Claude.[/spoiler]
Supergirl
But it is also good to have some mystery.

Why does everyone keep going on about Simone, she's gone. The preview I am positive is not what it seems. And didn't Kring like say Simone and Mohinder did not and will not have powers?
Tim Kring
QUOTE(Supergirl @ Mar 1 2007, 12:42 AM) [snapback]9844[/snapback]
But it is also good to have some mystery.

Why does everyone keep going on about Simone, she's gone. The preview I am positive is not what it seems. And didn't Kring like say Simone and Mohinder did not and will not have powers?


Tim Kring DID day that! SIMONE IS GONE!!!

I don't know why some people don't understand this! dry.gif
moneybanks
Maybe it was Simone?????

Just joking, yeah she's probably dead. But in my opinion i think it was maybe Charles Deveux (wateva).
Tim Kring
QUOTE(moneybanks @ Mar 1 2007, 03:35 AM) [snapback]9875[/snapback]
Maybe it was Simone?????

Just joking, yeah she's probably dead. But in my opinion i think it was maybe Charles Deveux (wateva).


Unno, that could be very plausible... But I think it is on the edge of being Far-Fetched... wink.gif

Thanks for the thoughts though!

-ALic wink.gif
Aerdna
What about Meredith? She was supposedly "dead" for sometime. Only thing that rules that out is that HRG doesn't even know that Meredith's alive, but did HRG ever find out who Claude was hiding in the first place? I'm so confused...
Tim Kring
We all are confused!

The show's writters will be sure to answer our questions in time! THEY ARE A LOT BETTER THAN THE WRITTERS OF "LOST!"

So yeah, we will find out soon enough!
Jester77
QUOTE
What about Meredith? She was supposedly "dead" for sometime. Only thing that rules that out is that HRG doesn't even know that Meredith's alive, but did HRG ever find out who Claude was hiding in the first place? I'm so confused...


It could always be that we don't even know the person that Claude was hiding though I doubt that will be the case. I don't think that it is Meredith though since I believe that she was on the run at that point
Azkary
QUOTE(Jester77 @ Mar 3 2007, 02:23 PM) [snapback]10304[/snapback]
It could always be that we don't even know the person that Claude was hiding though I doubt that will be the case. I don't think that it is Meredith though since I believe that she was on the run at that point



That's exactly why he could have been protecting her. How can you start a new life when you're hiding from people who think you're dead? Someone must have helped her.
Jester77
QUOTE
That's exactly why he could have been protecting her. How can you start a new life when you're hiding from people who think you're dead? Someone must have helped her.


I don't think that it was Claude though after all he was hiding the person 7 years after Meredith supposedly died and she would have been on the run at that point
Tim Kring
QUOTE(Jester77 @ Mar 5 2007, 04:59 PM) [snapback]10836[/snapback]
I don't think that it was Claude though after all he was hiding the person 7 years after Meredith supposedly died and she would have been on the run at that point


Hmmmmm...

Hopefully they reveal it soon...
Jester77
QUOTE
Hopefully they reveal it soon...


Well if you can call soon at least 7 weeks away then it'll most definetly be answered soon biggrin.gif
Tim Kring
QUOTE(Jester77 @ Mar 6 2007, 08:06 PM) [snapback]11476[/snapback]
Well if you can call soon at least 7 weeks away then it'll most definetly be answered soon biggrin.gif


6 weeks and 5 days!

TOLD YOU THIS WAS GONNA BE FAST!
Jester77
QUOTE
6 weeks and 5 days!

TOLD YOU THIS WAS GONNA BE FAST!


Hah more like 6 weeks and 3 days now..oh man the new episodes are coming fast biggrin.gif
Tim Kring
QUOTE(Jester77 @ Mar 9 2007, 06:24 PM) [snapback]12605[/snapback]
Hah more like 6 weeks and 3 days now..oh man the new episodes are coming fast biggrin.gif


I love your sarcasm... dry.gif
Jester77
QUOTE
I love your sarcasm...


Sorry well hey if you want to know more about Heroes go watch the episode commentaries, the graphic novels, and all the blogs at nbc.com
lyfe255754
i was thinking bak in company man hrg shot claude because he was hiding a evolved human. at first i thought it was claire. ya know no big. hrg was hiding claire too but he had 2 shoo him to cover his own arse, but then i saw an interview an they say we all kno KNOW who he was hiding. and from out of nowhere i think. maybe he was hiding claires mom.
Jester77
QUOTE
i was thinking bak in company man hrg shot claude because he was hiding a evolved human. at first i thought it was claire. ya know no big. hrg was hiding claire too but he had 2 shoo him to cover his own arse, but then i saw an interview an they say we all kno KNOW who he was hiding. and from out of nowhere i think. maybe he was hiding claires mom.


That has been the popular idea of late and can you put a link up for the interview where they said that, please
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.